The challenge
A first-time cycle during peak season, run by a Chief of Staff with no HR team
Without an HR team (and even often with one), performance reviews typically mean long hours, scattered spreadsheets, and immense administrative burden. For Emily, Nirvana’s Chief of Staff, this would be her first time orchestrating a performance review cycle, and as a company running mid-year reviews during their busiest season, efficiency was crucial.
“The second half of the year is by far our busiest period, so when it came to performance reviews, I was hesitant to introduce a process that could disrupt or distract the team from their day-to-day work.”
With Windmill, she ran an organized, efficient mid-year cycle with a 100% completion rate for self and upward reviews.
Median completion times:
- Peer Review: 5 minutes
- Upward Review: 16 minutes
- Self Review: 50 minutes
Plus an ~80% preference for Windmill among employees who had prior performance review experience.
The solution
Months of feedback already in Windmill gave the cycle instant credibility
Introducing a new performance review process often leads to fielding endless questions, but Windmill’s approach, building on months of data already collected by the platform, gave the process immediate credibility and familiarity.
Nirvana started using Windmill in the early summer to collect ongoing feedback. With months of rich data already in the platform, it made running performance reviews with Windmill the clear choice, so managers could draw directly from the insights Windy had captured.
Users described the process as:
Faster and easier to understand what the company wanted to hear from me
Compared to my previous review, this one gave me more concrete examples and practical takeaways
The experience
Reviews in Slack felt like a conversation, not a form
Windmill’s conversational Slack format prompted deeper reflection without the intimidation of staring at a blank document. Employees shared feedback like “it felt more like a two-way dialogue.”
Nirvana also avoided the problem of introducing new software by keeping the majority of the employee experience in Slack, where they already work.
“Our management team had already been using Windmill to collect other types of feedback, and because Slack is part of our everyday workflow, the rest of the team was immediately very comfortable engaging with Windy there—which made the whole process extremely low-lift.”
Employees described it as:
Natural, like a conversation
Easier than writing in a Google Doc
Convenient not having to access something else
For Nirvana’s distributed team, including international contractors, the familiar interface eliminated training overhead and made coordination seamless.
Running the cycle
A first-time admin ran the whole cycle, calibration included, without chasing anyone down
Beyond the employee experience, Windmill turned performance reviews into a seamless operational process, even for someone who had never run a cycle before.
“Running this process manually like we used to—chasing people down, stitching together information across different systems and spreadsheets—would've taken an unbelievable amount of time. I honestly can't imagine doing it that way now.”
She particularly valued the calibration module:
“Using the calibration module in Windmill was my favorite part of the process. It is so, so helpful. Having all of the information in one place, in a really easy to read way, made our performance conversations so much more productive.”
As one of Windmill’s earliest performance review customers, Nirvana also benefited from collaboration with the team. When Nirvana had feature requests mid-cycle, Windmill deployed a solution, sometimes shipping changes in as little as 12 hours.






